BroadwayNerdd

2) Barbossa’s interest in the Trident and the Ruby In DMTNT we learn that Barbossa is Catrina’s father and that her father was at least for at while, very interested in finding the trident of poseidon, and that he left a book with her of his notes. The following theory explains how  barbossa would have come to know of such a trident and why he might want it. The start of this explanation kind of builds off the last one of Jack finding the trident back when he was a teen in the books (that theory is explained  Here), and later giving it up because he didn’t want the responsibility. We already know from the film’s that

2) Barbossa’s interest in the Trident and the Ruby In DMTNT we learn that Barbossa is Catrina’s father and that her father was at least for at while, very interested in finding the trident of poseidon, and that he left a book with her of his notes. The following theory explains how barbossa would have come to know of such a trident and why he might want it. The start of this explanation kind of builds off the last one of Jack finding the trident back when he was a teen in the books (that theory is explained Here), and later giving it up because he didn’t want the responsibility. We already know from the film’s that p

Since the release of Dead Men Tell No Tales, question has come forward within the fandom (especially those who are fans of the YA book series) of if or not the books can truly be canon or not anymore. Evidence strongly suggests that the writers of DMTNT likely forgot the book all together when writing the script for the final film. Either this or the completely disregarded them all together, because why else would DMTNT contain so many blatant contradictions with the YA novels? However, being a Young Jack Sparrow superfan I refuse to accept that the book series-which lasts 13 parts can be anything other than canon. So, here I have compiled m